
Catching Elephant is a theme by Andy Taylor
Congratulations! I’m going to reply to this publicly in case anyone else has some good recommendations.
Off the top of my head - I’d start by looking into Frankies 457 (great food and they have a beautiful and separate backyard/back room that would be great for a small private reception), The Vanderbilt (I don’t know much about their wine list but they have good beer and cocktails and you might be able to bring in your own wine if you don’t like their options), or Saul for something a little fancier. I’ve never been to the River Cafe but I hear they rent their private garden for events.
Hope that helps!